Teaching and Tasties

Delicious eats and daring, death-defying teaching feats

Obama say wha? September 29, 2008

Filed under: Random — tlsussman @ 4:48 pm

Bilingual education.  Constantly a topic of discussion, and more often, contention.  After spending two years to gain a masters in bilingual education, you would think I have all the answers.  Then I read an article, recently posted in the NY times.  Obama is all for bilingual education (yes!!!) and making sure students are literate in their native language before embarking on their journey into biliteracy.  YAY FOR COMMON SENSE!  If you are illiterate in your native language, you have NOTHING to build on and use to help learn the second.  This should be common sense.  Apparently, however, in some public school in New York, English immersion has worked.  Great.  That is definitely a possibility.  BUT…do they consider the students’ backgrounds?  If students arrive literate, there is less issue (mind you, not NO issue) with English immersion, than if they have never been to school a day in their lives.

We all have a story about a family member or friend that didn’t get special schooling, but still managed to learn English.  Great.  Congratulations!  Research clearly proves that those who receive support in their native language will actually do better in the second language.

Just think of all the immigrants you know.  They are not dumb – in fact, many of them know way more than I do.  They usually just don’t have the words to communicate.  Therefore, it is quite obvious that students could succeed on the math portion of standardized tests, especially if there is little writing.  That does not mean that could not use support in the primary language.  Besides, every child has the right to maintain his native language and culture.  More than a right, this of such importance – it is his identity, his connection to family and a connection to everything he was up to this point.  To take these things away is to tell a child that his background and history are not valid.  By doing that, you already lower his chances of success drastically.

Besides, what’s so bad about being bilingual or trilingual??  In fact, it is an advantage and a gift.  Hells yeah to Obama for pushing bilingual ed.


One Response to “Obama say wha?”

  1. Laura Says:

    I totally read that article by the dude who doesn’t know anything about bilingual education…. he was talking about Sixth Street Charter School, right? Sarah forwarded it to me. I should forward you the editorial I wrote to the NY Times about it. What really annoys me is that most people do know realize that they have experienced bilingual education themselves. If they have EVER had anything translated into their native language for them, well, that’s bilingual education at its most basic. The problem with the NY Times article was that there was no research to explain the results. There was absolutely nothing to show any correlation between English immersion and higher test scores. I lambasted the author in my editorial for neglecting to perform any kind of research before drawing conclusions about what should happen in nationwide education policy. …… Really, it makes me question the intelligence of those NY Times editors…..

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s